Saturday, March 23, 2013

Tourism and terrorism: What’s in common? - Out of the Box 26

By Renton de Alwis


There is potent power in tourism to avert some of the causes for terrorism. That indeed is a strong statement and my attempt in this column I wrote in the first week of October, 2010 for the ‘Daily Financial Times, Sri Lanka’ was to explore the relationship between these two phenomena. For us in Sri Lanka there are many lessons to learn and there is the definite need to ensure that we wipe out all the causes that cause terrorism to raise its ugly head.   

 
Just this week, the US and UK governments issued warnings for its citizens not to travel within Europe. Last month the Eiffel tower was closed for visitors for there was a threat of a terrorist attack. Many a time air planes come circling back after take-off, for a mystery caller had said there is a bomb on board. Panic sets in, crisis management plans are put to action, airports are closed, security is tightened, shoes are removed, belts taken off and body searches are made.


All studies point to the fact that terrorism is the single most negative phenomenon to impact on tourism ever. Be it in Egypt, Bali, Colombia, Jordon, Thailand, Kenya, Sri Lanka, Ireland, Mumbai, New York, Paris or London, terrorism is a sure dampener on the movement of travel. It prevents nations and people from realising the many socio-economic opportunities travel and tourism offers.   


Up until 9/11 and its impact on the world, only some nations were singled out as terrorist hotspots and it was more or less an issue of travel warnings to those destinations that prevailed. With 9/11 and the realisation that terrorism had deeper roots than issues touching on a few racial groups or ‘freedom fighters’, the face of the whole equation changed.


There were consistent efforts by organisations such as the UNWTO, WTTC, ESCAP and PATA within earlier decades to work towards having visa restrictions eased to facilitate better movement of travellers around the world. Huge progress was seen in this area at the time, except in some countries where internal terrorist threats were at a peak.  The incident of 9/11 changed all of that too and today we are witnessing a reversal of that trend and even a selective process of the application of visa and other travel movement restrictions, together with more and more frequent calls for action on curbing terrorism.


Nothing in this is new to us Sri Lankans. For nearly thirty years we suffered this same fate. We had our airport attacked and airplanes destroyed on the tarmac, explosions close to hotels, lives lost, visas being imposed for our travel by almost every country in the world.  We had an overall down on visitor arrivals with tourism fighting a constant battle with terrorism.


Today, thankfully we have overcome those threats within this nation and are gearing to seek ways to establish a lasting peace to reap the fruits of a growing tourism.


We have as a nation, upon that beating now realised that establishing that elusive lasting peace and keeping possible terrorist threats from raising its ugly head again, is indeed about generating understanding between people, respecting each other, appreciating our different and diverse ways, providing social and economic opportunities, while treating each other with dignity and honour. 


That then takes me to the question I raised on my column title. What’s common about tourism and terrorism? Indeed they are both similar sounding terms, yet having meaning as diverse as anything we know to be, can be. Tourism is a movement of people across seas and lands, their cultures and heritage, about creating bondages and friendships to generate better human understanding. It is about education and learning to be tolerant of each other. It is a movement that facilitates the appreciation of differences in each other’s way of doing things, faiths and beliefs and contributing to the greater good of people.

 
Terrorism, on the other hand is about using destructive methods to achieve an end. An end desired by a group of people who believe, that using weapons of terror is the only way to gaining recognition and focus on an issue. It is about generating chaos and mayhem and causes disunity and disintegration of societies and people.


Both tourism and terrorism have at the very base of its operation aspects that warrant and demand the attention of all of human kind. In tourism, it is to ensure that it brings positive aspects of its delivery as intended and do not focus on merely the ‘having a good time’ aspects, at cost to the communities ands societies it operates in. Terrorism on the other hand reflects what is basically faulty in mankind’s attempt at seeking more at the expense of those who have little or no access to resources, rights or opportunities. It also reflects the intolerance of others’ ways that prevail and makes a violent call for its correction.

 
Tourism has most of the ingredients needed to address the causes of what, has led to the creation of terrorism. It is about peace, about greater understanding and appreciation, about tolerance and at its very best, about sharing and caring. Together with initiatives such as seeing a world where religious and cultural conflicts are minimal, weapons of mass destruction or weapons of any sort are taken away from the arsenal of all nations; powerful, emerging or otherwise, tourism has the potential of making its mark in building a better world.

 
Sri Lanka made a mark on the world at large, as a nation that defeated one of the most vicious terrorist groups in the world with much sacrifice and cost. Now it is the same nation that can demonstrate, that it is doing its’ all to address terrorisms’ root causes. We do have the resolve but have a long way to go down that road. Tourism is a strong pillar that is used to support our efforts and therein, we may find the answers to heal old wounds, to sooth hurt and to learn of ways to find unity within our diversity.

 
For both tourism and terrorism, desired outcomes will depend not on words alone but on solid, committed action by all, taken on with a strong and well-focussed will to succeed.
 
 

 Free Google Image

 

 

Friday, March 22, 2013

The many faces of tourism - Out of the Box 25

By Renton de Alwis

 
We need to think different if we need to save our heritage and natural resources. This column written in September 2010 was an attempt to show an approach away from conventional thought to ensure that we achieve the objectives of earning fast returns and saving our resources from destruction. A repost from ‘Daily Financial Times, Sri Lanka’.

 

Last week my column was about my experience in walking through casinos in Macau (SAR) of China and of the concept of integrated resorts. I shared with readers how integrated resorts were used to contain hundreds of thousands of people in a world of dreams, within an artificially created environment. I had several readers sending me e-mails commenting on what they thought of the proposition I was making. Most said they never thought that one could contain such large numbers of visitors within buildings and wanted to study more of the concept. 

One caught my attention in particular, for that reader was upset with the thought that, I was promoting casinos for Sri Lanka. I did respond to him firmly stating that, it is not my intent and thought it would be good for me to make a clarification today, lest I be misunderstood.

What I did not tell him though is that, there is a lot of hypocrisy in the way in which we think about gaming. Most of those who say that casinos are not to be, forget that most Sri Lankan families each evening sit together in front of their TV screens, to play the various lottery games available. Within the city of Colombo, even in close proximity to schools, casinos carry on business as usual.

The proposition I make is that we contain all of that in a single area, to achieve the targets set for tourism while making rapid ROI, containing the need to ‘develop’ facilities all around the country, for the millions of visitors, we expect to have. It is indeed a pragmatic plea for conserving our valuable bio-diversity rich natural and culturally vibrant heritage resources, for the longer term. What I learnt as a conservation economist; is that the best way to conserve a threatened resource, is by providing an alternative to replace it.  

On a recent visit to Pollonnaruwa, we observed how the old bricks at several heritage sites were showing signs of wear, as a result of over-visitation to those particular areas. Some were even seen to be disintegrating. Each of our heritage sites as well as our cultural resources has a limit or a carrying capacity of what it can take, without causing irreparable damage to its form and content.     

As I have maintained through out my career in this industry, tourism is a two-edged word. In the wrong hands and ill-managed, tourism can do much damage to a country’s natural, cultural and human resources. Similarly, when well-managed, tourism can be a most potent and productive endeavour contributing to uplift the lives of communities, providing employment, incomes, education, enriching local cultures and contribute towards conservation of resources.

This year Sri Lanka expects to have nearly 700,000 visitors. In about half a decade, the number is to reach 2.5 million according to our tourism planners. A friend of mine exclaimed with a “But that’s half our population?” in response to a politician’s claim that tourism will need 10 million people to service its needs in the future. 

It is most unfortunate that many who talk about tourism or even get involved in its planning and management have not been exposed adequately to its manifold faces. They know only of a few popular models and continue attempts to replant some of them on our domain. Within Sri Lanka, there are of course exceptions to this rule. One well known contributor is of course, architect guru Late Geoffrey Bawa. The innovative spirit, creativity and the local feel he brought to our hotel and resort architecture stands testimony to his great contribution to tourism. To him a hotel was not just another well designed building, but a platform to create a holistic visitor experience.

I have heard of an instance when he chased away a rock music group that was about to perform in the lobby of the Light House Hotel in Galle, for that was not to be the mood he had envisaged for his creation. Later, the amplified sounds were replaced with mellow melodies of a bamboo flute. 

I also know of an enlightened tourism entrepreneur, who prior to designing a tourist hotel took a tour studying best practices at destinations such as Bali, Chiang Mai, Sarawak and the like. He spent weeks at each, learning of the why and the how of those experiences and the facility he developed is today a hit with high-end visitors as well as being an award winner.

Within tourism’s many faces we could also explore many options. Home stay based resorts, boat-houses, soft and hard adventure, creating dream experiences, opportunities for volunteering, cultural interactions, mega-integrated resorts, eco-lodges, niche developments, tea-trails, ancient heritage explorations, colonial heritage explorations, wildlife explorations, study of elephants, ornithology explorations, sea mammal explorations, sailing and angling explorations … the list can be long and the faces are many. 
 
  
Free Google Image
 

Monday, March 18, 2013

It’s all on your palm - Out of the Box 24

By Renton de Alwis

Info-communication technology has brought the world of knowledge exploration to the top of our palms today. It has empowered the user to be much more informed and be more sensitive to the environments of the places they visit. It indeed is a double-edged sword and need be used by both generator of content and the receiver in a responsible manner. I sought to explore its potential for creating awareness of tourism offers and the sharing of travel experiences, in this column I wrote for the ‘Daily Financial Times, Sri Lanka’ in September, 2010.


It’s true that it’s written on your palm. In the old days, it was the palm-reader or the palmist that told you, on reading those unique lines, what the future holds for you. Part fun - part science - part creativity, the claim goes. Today, it’s that device on your palm that brings you the news as it happens, the time, the weather, market information, giving you directions to get to places, even bringing you vivid images of them, linking you with friends, with people you are yet to see or get to know, from anywhere in the world. You can move them, flip them, save them for recall or even dump them, when you don’t need them.

Not all of us in Sri Lanka have them yet, but our customers are fast getting into the act. Soon, it will catch up with us. It is high-tech and high-touch, both at the same time.

Gone are the days when one had to carry loads of information in brochures or guide-books. Today there is increasing use of hand-held devices at heritage sites, museums and other places where unique experiences unfold. When learning is an important part of the sensory experience, the functionality of the device becomes more meaningful.

Until a few years ago, these were limited to museums and were bulky devices with equally bulky ear-phones worn on your head. But today, they are smaller and the amount of information stored is significant. Most have moved to create intense sensory experiences taking travellers back in time, place and space with dramatic sound bites, music and even visual material used in its creation. A visit to a site today can become a total emersion sensory experience. Some more enlightened tour operators and tour guides are actively encouraging travellers to use applications such as tracking their location on Geo-sat imagery and using e-guides for the destination. They consider the tool as a complementary device to enrich the experience, rather than being in competition with the services they provide.

The devices range from proprietary sets given on loan at sites to dial-up facilities on your own mobile phone, i-phone or other interactive palm-top. Just the other day, I learnt that it was possible to use applications to access the Bible, the Koran or the Bhagwath Githa. The religious experience that was once limited to a place of worship, is now travelling with you, held lightly on your palm. On call 24 x 7 as they say. Predictions are that these will become even more experiential, meeting demand as they develop.

Most of it is open-source and is content developed not by experts but by people the likes of you, experience seeking travellers. I read about a travel company that gave the funds, a timeline and asked an independent writer couple, to determine where they wanted to go, what they wanted to do and bring stories of the experiences they had, back to the company. This was how they began their experiential travel business. I must repeat; it is high-tech, yet high touch.

Thereafter, they got their customers to tell their own stories of the experiences they had. These were on blogs and complete freedom was given to each of the customers to design their own dream experience. The only condition was that they had to be responsible and reasonable. It is interactivity at its best, made possible through the new info-communication tools we now posses. They come in all forms and sorts and evolve day by day.

According to several studies on tourism futures, there are more and more hand held devices coming in now, to make the travel experience richer and better. Destinations are encouraging travellers to write their stories about what unfolded for them while on holiday. Singapore, Malaysia and our own Sri Lanka Tourism, have called on travellers to blog-in their stories. Destination promoters have developed tag-lines that describe their destinations with close emotional ties with customers. ‘Your Singapore’ and ‘Touch your heart’ for Taiwan, are two current examples.

On another plain there is travel distribution happening on mobile devices. A threesome group of Greek university professors cite tourism as the first industry to use information technology in its applications. Dating back to the 1960’s tourism was using Computer Reservation Systems (CRS) and Global Distribution Systems (GDS), facilitating travel agents to book airline seats and packaged tours. Today, that has advanced to accessing on-line auctions of airline seats and hotel rooms, which are perishable.

We in Sri Lanka are now on the fast-track on info-communications development. The latest in technology is with us and the coverage is expanding. The speeds are growing. Our tourism can be a beneficiary, not only through providing connectivity. We need to be creative in its use and make our experiential offers be even better. It’s not all about palmtops and technology. We need to get the rest of it right.

It’s about getting the right balance in being high-tech, while retaining our high-touch.  
 
    

  Shared Google Image 

Sunday, March 17, 2013

Is sky the limit for our tourism? - Out of the Box 23

Renton de Alwis


As far back as 1974, I had the opportunity to be part of a team that worked on a project called “An Unsteady State: Problems of Growth, Culture and Environment”. That was when I was a post graduate student working on a special workshop that was the preamble, to set in place the Environment Institute at the East West Center in Hawaii. As a student of economics who also wrote poetry, I was a member of the ‘Open Grants’ group at the centre then. It was also the same time that, President Obama’s mother Anne Dunham was a colleague attached to the Culture Learning Institute of the EWC.


This one and half year workshop was conducted by Prof. Kenneth Watt from the University of California at Davis, who had at the time authored the book “The Titanic Effect”, suggesting that the way the US was exploiting her resources could lead to its sinking in the future. And that was in 1995 and he was called a ‘doomsday soothsayer’ by many.

At the workshop, in teams we examined what he termed ‘Dominant Cultural Beliefs’  and they were all to do with what were then accepted as the ‘truth’, in relation to how the world saw its way forward in growing its lot. They were the likes of  ‘Chemical fertilisers increase production’, ‘Growth is desirable’, ‘Greed is good’ and more. While the empirical evidence showed that they were all valid in the short term and some in the medium term, all were found to be false in the long term.  And then, most thought and asked “we are all dead in the long term... so why worry? “

That was decades ago. Today we have seen, what the outcomes have been. Alternative energy sources are now touted as the best options, when 40 years ago, when presented as options, they were scantily disregarded. The conventional energy lobby was more powerful then, than it is today.

When we depend on our environment and its resources to live and further our quality of life, we need to be mindful of how we should be on that journey. Tourism is no different. And at Sri Lanka tourism, we have lots of lessons we can draw from elsewhere,  to observe how things had gone wrong when they followed the conventional model.

I repost this column I wrote for the ‘Daily Financial Times, Sri Lanka’ in June 1210, as food for thought on this Sunday morning.
 

I read a headline in a leading business journal recently which said “Sky is the limit for Sri Lanka Tourism”. The story referred to the statistics of a 50% increase in visitor arrivals, year to year, period to period and talked about expectations for the coming winter season. This is all excellent. For we in Sri Lanka have a visitor base of manageable proportions and the impact on our natural and heritage resources are still at reasonably low levels. In fact, the unique selling proposition (USP) Sri Lanka as a destination will have for the future, are the relatively pristine natural environment, our cultural heritage and the evergreen smiles we have to offer.

From a tourism point of view those past years of conflict, has now given us an edge and an advantage, not many other destinations in Asia can boast about; i.e. a place in the sun which is not over-crowded, where serendipity still finds its meaning and our culture still remains relatively unpolluted by dominant influences of rapid growth. We must also find solace in the fact that planners of tourism in the early days were thoughtful and wise.

As far back as 1967, when tourism became a formal business activity in then Ceylon, a group of consultants from Hawaii who prepared a tourism development plan recommended that ‘no resort or hotel development on the coasts of Ceylon should be taller than a coconut tree’. It was just a rule of thumb recommendation, but its positive impact for our tourism today is of great value. Except for one or two sad exceptions, all of Sri Lanka’s coastal tourism development is not above three stories high and is covered with the green canopy of our coconut palms.

I am sure our tourism planners will make good of this unique advantage we have and continue not to over build. Thanks to our innovative architectural heritage both in ancient and in more recent times, we have a group of thinking people who are able to present most appropriate, sustainable and innovative designs. The urge to grow tall and reach the sky as fast as possible, seem to be with some segments of our leadership whose planning horizons only stretch out to be between elections. They need to prove themselves, show fast and glittering results to impress to safeguard their positions with the leadership.

We hear of politicians, even those with sound credentials, accuse conservation activists as been the bane of economic growth. “These types keep investors away” is how they are described. There are many among investors and business persons who are also out for the kill. Their planning horizons extend to the next project and then on to the next. The consideration is only on how much profit can be made now and then with that stored away, move on to the next. The nation’s interest is on the back-burners and only fast gain and their own survival is up in-front. We indeed need foreign investors, but not all and sundry who come in with the first proposal and are ready to oil palms. We must have patience to seek the best and be transparent about the process with which we select them. In tourism too, we must learn to say no, like we have said to others who seek to impose their will on us. We shall soon realise that the best among investors, who are in it for the long- term will appreciate our position and seek to support us.

What that would mean are quality products and services, higher returns and yield, less forex leakages, more sustainable environmental outcomes and direct benefits to local communities. We see on our midst those who are in the industry for nothing but short-term gain. They build, operate, enhance share value with fast cash making schemes and sell to make a kill and in the process do lots of damage to the destination and its image.

Sri Lanka tourism has a visitor arrivals target of 2.5 million to be achieved by 2016, as set in the ‘Mahinda Chinthana’ - Way Forward’, vision and strategy document.  That to me is a modest and reasonable expectation of our tourism and can be the ‘limit in the sky’ for us. While that target and the higher yields we must aim at, would give our economy and the nation what our natural, cultural and social resource base can reasonably withstand, our attention must be placed on how we pace towards that target. 2016 is six years away and that to most it is the long-term. What we must be cautious about are those whose expectation horizons are limited to a year or two, for they will want to reap benefits as some seem to call ‘the lost opportunities of the past three decades’, with fast forward rapid action. A good example is the lack of the intensity of this rush of investors to areas of the North and the East, where necessities are greater but immediate gain is limited.

We must remember that the same vision and strategy outlines a more equitable development of our nation’s economy. The thinking is similar to that proposed a decade or so ago, by the King of Thailand as the ‘Sufficiency Economy’ model for a country’s development. That however did not take root in that country as intended. It proposed a middle path balancing personal gain in investment with that of the wider society, placing national interest over self-interest.

We can indeed reach the skies if we play it right. But that sky must be blue and not fog-ridden. It must be a sky that will allow the sun to shine on all citizens alike. We must take time to reach that sky and not be in a hurry. Then and then only will the sky be our limit.  
 
Shared Google Image    

 

    

Saturday, March 16, 2013

A tree talks ...without complaint.

A shared Google image. Thank you Joanne for sharing your creative work


Beyond the smiles - Out of the Box 22

By Renton de Alwis

Repost of a column I wrote in July, 2010 in the ‘Daily Financial Times, Sri Lanka’ examined the need for maintaining our brand identity of being a destination that offers an experience combing nature, culture, heritage and adventure of a  friendly and hospitable people. We are indeed a blessed land in terms of our natural endowment and it is for us to ensure that we conserve it, through the training and education of people to take care of it,  for that is value that is unique to us and can make us stand tall in the ‘crowd’ with other destinations.


At every two year interval, an exit survey is conducted by Sri Lanka Tourism among visitors departing Sri Lanka. At each of these over many years, friendliness of our people and their smiles came at the top of list as the most appreciated aspect of their visit to our island nation. This was so, even at the height of our saga with terrorism when arrivals dropped to all time lows. We, Sri Lankans smiled and continue to smile naturally. Unlike some other destinations, we never had the need to carry out campaigns to ask our people to smile.

Today, we are in for good times and that is when we should be cautious and concerned about looking beyond those natural smiles to providing caring service. With an over 50% increases in visitor arrivals, and growing upwards, our hunger for visitors and their business as tourist guests, could face the danger of decline. Many destinations have had that experience in the past, in being in situations where when things were rosy, the service levels and caring ways dropped to lows, and regaining them once again, became a costly exercise. There is always the danger of us getting into that trap and we must exercise care to not look at visitors as money making machines, placing our hospitable and caring ways on the back-burners.

Now that there is enough tourism business around to place a smile on every tour operator’s, hotel owner’s, shop keeper’s and tour guide’s face, this perhaps is the right time for us to wean away from the most deplorable practise, of add-on commissions we had, for so long on the agenda of our tour operations. In the past, these accounted for mark-ups on goods bought at most jewellery and handicraft shops and spice gardens for up to 60 percent of its actual retail sales value.

Tourism is a service industry where service is spelt with a capital ‘S’. What was good about our caring ways in the past is that to most, it came naturally, and was in no way considered an add-on. For this to continue in good times, it is vital that we undertake a strong and wide-spread programme of training and development of human resources. Most of the larger corporate entities in tourism in Sri Lanka pay much attention to their training now. Human resources development is an integral part of their corporate strategy and members of their staff are direct beneficiaries of those initiatives.

Unfortunately, it is the smaller and more localised enterprises that do not get the benefit of such strategically designed programmes. 

Interestingly, this is not a phenomenon limited to our own country. In a recent book published by Abby Liu and Geoffrey Wall of the Faculty of Tourism, Aletheia University in Taiwan titled “Planning tourism employment: a developing country perspective”, the authors argue that “tourism planning should be about planning for residents as well as for visitors”. According to them “if tourism is to be a positive force in the lives of local residents, it is contingent upon local response, involvement and support”. They contend that “many tourism plans for developing area destinations give inadequate attention to human resources development. Furthermore, many tourism plans espouse forms of tourism that do not fit well with existing human resources capabilities, so that local people find it difficult to participate in tourism and, in consequence, benefit less than might otherwise be the case”. Substantiating the position enumerated earlier in this column, they say that “Human resources development often focuses on the employment needs of large international companies, especially in hospitality, to the neglect of the employment requirements and opportunities in tourism more broadly conceived”.

We do have regional tourism training institutes and one can argue that these meet the requirements in providing opportunities for local youth to participate in tourism endeavors. On an in-depth study of the curriculum offered, one can see that at most of these institutes, the skills training provided is to prepare youth to serve as paid employees at hotels, restaurants and other outfits of a corporate nature. There is little or none in content taught to develop initiative for them to become small tourism entrepreneurs on their own right. There is very little in content that teaches them to develop a culture of caring but a dishing out of a set of basic skills i.e. cookery, room service, restaurant service etc.

At these times when larger business entities take on serious corporate social responsibility initiatives, it is opportune that focus is placed on policies and strategies that will develop our tourism human resources to also become independent operators of their own in their own locales, rather than remaining as mere wage workers. Such strategy, will auger well to keep the smiles on, of communities that act as important catalysts in making the tourism experience at a destination like Sri Lanka, potent and bright.  
 
 
Pic credit: Self

Friday, March 15, 2013

Volume tourism verses ethical travel - Out of the Box 21

by Renton de Alwis

‘There is more to tourism than what meets the eye’ is the proposition I make in this repost of a June, 2010 column written for the ‘Daily Financial Times, Sri Lanka. I present it today for your critical thought.


Believe me, there is more to tourism than what meets the eye. What we see are the tourists; the statistics quoted by tourist boards of increasing numbers, some of the foreign exchange earned, commissions made on purchases, entrance fees to sites, hotel swimming pools filled with guests, pickings from the buffet tables, air-con coaches plying the roads, busy guides leading tour-parties, roadside vendors falling over each other to sell, beach operators, hotel lobbies, hustlers and convention attendees. I may have missed a few from the long random list of what they form, depending on who they are and what they want to do. Basically, what’s enumerated makes a good canvass of the tourism scenario as most of us observe and know.

But then, there is more to it than that. For tourism today, define another dimension that touches on better quality, being experiential, up-market giving higher yields, being conservationist and most of all being ethical. As I had discussed in an earlier column, this also forms the dividing line between a tourist and a traveler.
 
 
Jeff Greenwald & Christy Hoover in a report identifying the ‘10 best ethical destinations of the world for 2010’, defines ethical travel as “travel that is mindful: an awareness of our impact and responsibilities as we explore the world”. Reference to it can be found on the website at www.ethicaltraveler.org. A project of the Earth Island Initiative, located in Berkeley, California it was founded by David Brower, the first executive director of the Sierra Club. The objective of identifying the ten best ethical travel destinations of the developing world is to “steer travelers toward countries that are working hard to protect human rights, build social welfare, and preserve the environment”.     

The report goes on to state that since travel and tourism has become one of the planet's largest industries - on par with oil – identifying the economic power of travelers, to be  enormous. It cites the questions before ethical travelers to be those such as “Which countries should we visit? Where should we spend our money when we get there? How do our interactions with our hosts promote international goodwill and cross-cultural understanding?”

Unlike many other organizations that is critical of tourism for its negative impacts the ‘Ethical Traveler’ views all travel as a potentially positive act. They “like to see people step off the beaten path” and states that the places on their annual list may not be as popular yet as Thailand or Italy, but they abound in natural wonders and fascinating cultures. These destinations are “serious about preserving their natural assets, promoting mindful-travel and building an economy in which local communities reap the benefits of tourist revenue”. The Ethical Traveler claims that “travel to these countries encourages such efforts, and inspires neighboring countries to support these values as well” making a clarion call to support such travel.

The nominated list for 2010 includes destinations Argentina, Belize, Chile, Ghana, Lithuania, Namibia, Poland, Seychelles, South Africa and Suriname and notably excludes all Asian destinations. With the prime nomination criteria being environmental protection, social welfare and sensitivity to preserving human rights, this is indeed an alarming situation. 


In an explanation, the report says that “the global economic downturn has inevitably hindered efforts towards sustainability, responsible tourism, and environmental stewardship, even in highly developed countries. Progress in these very important areas tends to decline in times of economic hardship. Given that developing countries with a strong reliance on the tourism sector have been particularly hard hit, we have seen a slowing of progress almost across the board”.

Notably, not a single Asian country made it to the Top 10. Irresponsible development, human rights abuses, and a lack of strong environmental policy kept them all off the list again this year. Perhaps surprisingly, though, four African countries - three on the mainland, and one island republic - made the final list. We believe this bodes well for the future of these nations and, hopefully, for the African continent”.

Costa Rica, a destination that made the top of the list in 2008, has dropped off as a result of the alarming increase in the incidence of the sex trade related to its tourism. Several other destinations have not made this list and its designers themselves have admitted that it to be not an all perfect presentation.

 
The point I wish to make is not about its accuracy or its validity. It is about the fact that the world of travel and tourism is moving in a direction that will be very different to what we knew in the past. Ethical travel is but only one such element of that direction. There are many others that define high yield travel that has to do with the conservation of our natural resources, providing dignity and direct benefits to the communities, it touches.


We would do well at this time of our seeking tourism growth, to ensure that social ills associated with tourism are minimized. What it takes is sound mindful thinking based action on the investment, product development and promotional fronts.
 
 
 
Shared Google Image

Thursday, March 14, 2013

Tourism: A potent thrust for lasting peace - Out of the Box 20

by Renton de Alwis

Hope and a wish that never again should we see, an era as dark as the 3o years we saw in our recent history and the several other sad conflicts where several thousand young lives were lost in vain. Tourism’s potential for making peace was explored in this column written in June, 2010, a year after the end of the war on terrorism in the ‘Daily Financial Times, Sri Lanka’. Today’s is a repost of that article.


We in tourism have always been victims of the political games that are played. Be it,  unstable governance structures, tensions and conflicts between countries, recessions, pandemics, concerns about global warming, uneasy trade negotiations, racial conflicts, environmental disasters, street demonstrations, student unrest, revolts or deadly terrorist movements; every socio-economic or political upheaval or event has and will hurt and/or impact tourism. To have stability, devoid of these for travel and tourism, is a basic need. Safety, security and a calm atmosphere in and around a tourist destination, is a given pre-requisite for its sustenance and development. 

In the main, and sometimes regretfully, we in tourism have played the role of uninvolved bystanders during these upheavals and events and have lived in hope that they will go away. We have treated them mostly as externalities and never attempted to do our bit to help resolve them. Our thirty year struggle with terrorism and the many ups and downs tourism had since 1983 are a clear indicator of how bad things can be. As an industry, our tourism was grasping for breath, yearning for new leases of life, with each bad incident and escalation in violence. We called ourselves resilient and with each hit, dusted ourselves, gathered the pieces and moved on to rebuild and regain what little we could.

Thankfully, that new lease of life has now begun. Terrorism was militarily defeated. Many of our citizens in the armed forces as well as civilians gave their lives to bring that resolve to our Motherland. There is relative peace and calm all around. Potent attempts are made to reach-out to those who have been innocent victims of this struggle as well as ex-combatants, to bring back normalcy to their lives. Reconciliation and unification is sought where honour and dignity of those involved, need be guaranteed.

On the part of tourism, investors, strategists, service providers and operators are all rushing-in to catch up on lost time. Land-grabs are on and each looks for the best and the most scenic place to build a hotel or a resort. Bankers who were once tight fisted, being hurt with tourism lending, are now sporting inviting smiles. We have recorded near 50 per cent increases of our tourist arrivals compared with the last year. Foundation stones are laid for new hotels and resorts that are soon to be built. The Yal Devi is once again on its tracks and the A-9 road opens new vistas for developing the North for tourism. Hundreds of thousand Southern pilgrims are visiting the North, often placing a strain on the limited resources available. There is free flow of people of all races, and goods of all sizes, between these areas. Already, the East is seeing a revival with Passikudah, Vakarai, Trincomalee and Nilaveli being energised. Arugam-bay which was a potent destination for surfers even during troubled times is now once again becoming a vibrant place.

This movement of travel and tourism is indeed a potent thrust for human interaction. It needs sensitive handling and much care in its nurturing. For us in the industry there are many lessons to be learnt. We can not expect that all of this will continue to be the same, without an effort from us to make sure that it will continue to be that way.  In the past, whenever we were hurt, we looked toward state’s help. Reschedule loans, tax breaks for imports for refurbishment, preferential electricity tariffs were calls made at every meeting of industry personnel. Even in adversity the State did what it could to support the much touted public-private partnership that is tourism in Sri Lanka.

Today, from a pure business sense, there is relative peace and an environment where tourism can thrive. But it may not be all rosy as may seem. There are UN probes, an active semblance among the Diaspora working to undermine whatever is done to build national reunification and the EU concessions of GST for the apparel industry are hanging in the balance. Within our culture of undermining even the best of initiatives if ‘they are from those we do not support’; even cocktail circuit talk, focus more on the negatives than the positives.  

It is time that we as an industry realize that we need to actively support peace, national reunification and the sustenance of outcomes that are good, if we are to continue to gain from the tough achievements that have been made in being rid of terrorism. What is needed is active involvement in the process, by an industry whose very survival depends on the continuance of a peaceful environment. Peace is elusive and must not be taken for granted. Each of our drops of assertive contributions will go on to making what it takes to keep it all in place. Those in tourism cannot afford to be uninvolved bystanders anymore. There is a now a dire need to do whatever; however we can to further the process of national reconciliation and nurture the relative peace that has been achieved.

For tourism can indeed be a potent thrust for ensuring lasting peace for our Motherland. What we need to do is to factor that in strongly, into our operational agenda. 
 
    
Pix credit: Self

Wednesday, March 13, 2013

Lessons from Bali’s Ubud - Out of the Box 19

by Renton de Alwis

A repost of my column written for the ‘Financial Times, Sri Lanka’ in June 2010. My aim was to describe one of my favourite tourism destinations through the eyes of others, who had also experienced Ubud. It is also a case study of how folk tradition, cooperative effort and creative pursuits combine to make what can be a lesson in good tourism.

 
I hear many of my friends in tourism, talk about Ubud in a fond and joyous tone. A few months ago a much travelled friend (in travel media) and his wife from the USA, who live in a most picturesque area in San Francisco, visited Ubud for the first time and decribed it as “one of the most beautiful and mememorable experiences they have ever had”. Coming from them, I take it as a real ‘feather in the cap’ for this cozy little tourist destination.

Since I first visited Ubud in the 1980s and visited there several times thereafter, she stuck in my mind as what I would like most of Sri Lanka’s tourism destinations to emulate, if ever the need be. My readers must not misunderstand me and think that I wish Sri Lanka to be like any other. I certainly do not. Our island’s exotic uniquness is indeed unmatched and evokes a natural charm, astonioshing most visitors to our island.

A Sri Lankan friend whose young daughter born in the mainland USA, now living in another exotic destination in Hawaii’s Maui, had inserted a note she wrote on his Facebook page. It was a postcript on an email she wrote to her brother, to describe a recent visit to Sri Lanka “p.s. as crazy as it is..... sri lanka is the most beautiful country in the world... more beautiful than hawaii.... i dont know how my young immature mind missed it last time.. but it has progressed and is sooooo beautiful i cant believe it.. i have so many pictures.. . OMG we are sooooo lucky........ even more beautiful than my favorite… Bali.. and so less run over by tourism and the 21st century.. most all the goods (clean air, streets, modern living) and few of the bad (deeply poor people and polluted waters, and few shanty towns that are super shanty, but off to the side… so you might not even see if you were not looking. …weird”

Ubud, as decribed in the wikipedia is a town on the Indonesian island of Bali’s Ubud district, located amongst rice paddies and steep ravines in the central foothills of the Gianyar regency. One of Bali's major arts and culture centres, it has developed a large tourism industry. Ubud has a population of about 8,000 people, but it is becoming difficult to distinguish the town itself from the villages that surround it.

The secret of success of Ubud as a destination has been its ability to retain its charm and the charming ways of the villagers or you may call, the town people. Ubud’s craftpersons work in a commune type model. A painting created in their unique style will have several arists working on it, including young apprentices, each contributing a bit to its making. The carved wooden frames for the painting is also designed and made as part of the same task. It is as if, what they create is a devotional offering to their Hindu gods.  

According to the Wikipedia account, tourism on the island developed after the arrival of Walter Spies, an ethnic German born in Russia who taught painting and music, and dabbled in dance. Spies and foreign painters Willem Hofker and Rudolf Bonnet entertained celebrities including Charlie Chaplin, Noel Coward, Barbara Hutton, H.G. Wells and Vicki Baum. They brought in some of the greatest artists from all over … helping Ubud become the cultural centre of Bali.

A new burst of creative energy came in 1960s in the wake of Dutch painter Arie Smit (1916-), and development of the Young Artists Movement. There are many museums in Ubud, including the Museum Puri Lukisan and the Agung Rai Museum of Art.

The Bali tourist boom since the late 1960s has seen much change in its scape; however, Ubud was able to remain a centre of artistic pursuit, retaining much of its past in tact. Sri Lanka’s colurful mat-weavers’ village of Dumbara, mask-makers and puppeteers of Ambalangoda, silversmith’s of Rideegama, metal craftspersons of Gannoruwa, lace-makers of Dickwella, the various craft villagers of the Northern peninsular and other such centers of excellence around Sri Lanka can learn some valuable lessons from their counterparts in Ubud, on how to retain the charm of their traditions and its authentic presentation through community based cooperative effort, in the midst of modernity.

The lesson indeed is that we can learn from others, but only to draw on what is good, to build our own unique ways to high levels of quality, that can then be, the envy of others.   
 
Free Google image
Pix credit: Alice Teh
   

Tuesday, March 12, 2013

The flip-side of tourism - Out of the Box 18

by Renton de Alwis

It’s not often that policy makers, strategists and mangers of activities that generate rapid returns, take a break to stop and think about the long term impact of what they do. In the 1980’and 90’s when tourism was in its ‘the golden era’ around the world, there were international and regional pressure groups that emerged, who often made planners and implementers of tourism activities breathe a while, to stop and take note of such issues. It was a healthy development and one that benefitted the shaping of many destinations in Asia, Latin America, Africa and the Western hemisphere’s emerging nations of that time to be responsible tourism destinations, pulling away from the earlier three ‘S’ and R&R (rest & recreation) type activities that had developed earlier.

I repost this column of mine written in June 2010 for the ‘Financial Times, Sri Lanka’ with the hope that our tourism planners also take caution at this time when we in Sri Lanka are now engaged in a rapid paced growth path of the industry.

 
I am mindful that this column appears in a business journal, where its readers mostly seek information on the economy and the various sectors of business and its performance. In most instances, what we like to read and hear are of the positive side of things and not so much, the flip-side. Today we live in a world, where comfort factors for us are preserved with much effort and more uncomfortable issues get placed on the back-burners of our decision making agenda. As a friend of mine recently said “We live in a world where we either ‘sell or are sold to’, with little reference to understanding the ramifications of what we do have on the greater human community and it’s good”. I guess the recent addition to business concepts of seeking corporate social responsibility (CSR), is a refection of an attempt to deal with this issue. Sadly, CSR remains an appendage rather than a core element of the basic business culture of most of our operations.  

I have in my column today taken on a specific focus to attract your attention to the flip- side of tourism, for this column is on tourism. I do this with even more of a direct approach than I have done before, for I believe that ‘looking at the other side’ of what we do, needs to be presented with a more assertive approach than the attempts we make to ‘market or sell’ the already established dogma. I believe that the issues herein extend beyond the realm of tourism to all other areas of business as well.

Since this column will not allow me to explore each of the flip-side issues of tourism in detail, what I will attempt to do, is to attract your attention to the research, literature and action areas where these are discussed. My addressing these issues does not suggest that I fully agree with the views presented. Nevertheless, I believe they are worthy of consideration by all tourism policy makers, strategic planners, investors and operators of tourism businesses.

The Third World Network (TWN) is one of several organizations where ‘tourism alternatives’ have got a strong focus now, for over a decade. The name Anita Pleumarom, who coordinates the Tourism Investigation & Monitoring Team (tim-team) of the TWN, has been in the forefront with several other writers, in brining focus on these issues. I choose to present in summary the nature of some of the issues raised in tim-team publications to illustrate the concerns. Readers who wish to refer to them may do so through a Google search on subject headings.

Here are some of the flip-side issues raised:

1. Does tourism benefit the Third World? 

Says that governments of developing nations invariably justify the promotion of tourism as a driving force for economic development and questions this claim and says that it is time to stop treating tourism as a holy cow to be protected and nurtured at all costs.

2. Tourism, predatory and omnivorous –

‘Tourism consumes the places on which it alights,' says author Jeremy Seabrook in taking issue with its exaggerated claims of benefits for the host country and cautions decision makers to rethink strategies to ensure that community benefit and conservatory practices are maintained.

3. Financial leakages in tourism –

Any meaningful discussion of the benefits of tourism to a host country must address the issue of 'financial leakages' claims authors Minu Hemmati and Nina Koehler explaining the importance of retaining incomes generated through operational models that permit it.

4. Tourism, gender and equitable development -

Contrary to the claims of the UN World Tourism Organisation, the doors of tourism do not open to equal opportunities for women, but to scary worlds of inequities and exploitation; claims T T Sreekumar analyzing the negative impacts on women in areas such as prostitution.

5. Tourism feels the heat of global warming -

Climate is an essential resource for tourism and global warming is unquestionably a threat to tourism. Anita Pleumarom discusses the response of the industry to a threat to which it is contributing.

6. Tourism, biodiversity and indigenous peoples: New invitations for social change -

Most indigenous peoples are discovering that tourism is undermining their very basis for survival while suppressing the very cultural value systems which underlie biodiversity, says researcher Alison Johnston.

7. The myths of ecotourism -

John Mbaria questions the claim of touting ecotourism universally as 'responsible travel' to areas rich in wildlife that also helps to preserve the environment and to promote the well-being of the local people. He reports on Kenya's experience in raising serious doubts about such claims.

8. Will Angkor Wat survive the invasion of mass tourism? -

The temples of Angkor in Cambodia; those incredible monuments which have survived more than 1,000 years, including periods of great turbulence and decay, are now confronted by the greatest challenge of all from mass tourism says researcher Tom Fawthrop.

These are only some of the flip-side issues presented here for the purpose of attracting attention through illustration. The point I make is that, we as an industry and as a nation need to spend time and effort to reflect on these aspects for that will help ensure the sustainability and the good health of the tourism industry. Ignoring them, by placing them on the back-burners and not addressing them head-on, may mean the ‘killing of the goose that can lay ‘golden’ eggs’.  


A beach scene from Alexandria
A free Google image
posted by civicpole.net